Is a society more cohesive if everyone speaks the same language (and only that language)?
How do you argue with someone who thinks so?
My mom says that all the kids in her neighbourhood played together outside in a big group. Now she never sees crowds of kids like that. The suggestion was made that language plays a role. Our nearest neighbours speak Greek and Chinese as first languages, and yes, I suppose I never see the kids from those houses playing together. But there are other factors, right?
And what about my own childhood in Saudi Arabia? Navaz's mom didn't always speak English to her. Zabrina's never did. Lorraine and her brother had a Greek tutor. Yet we friends were very close.
And what about last year in Morocco? Oriane spoke French first, Maria Swedish, Julia Portuguese, Abderrahim a Berber language, Fatima Arabic, and so on. Depending on proficiency, who else was around, and sometimes mood, we would speak French or English or Spanish or, if people were feeling patient, Arabic. Yes, there was an English cluster within that--Alaina, Caitlyn, Eric, and I could curse, joke, mutter, obscure-reference, and slang-drop together in a different way--but does that diminish the importance of my friendship with Oriane?
And what about Rwanda and Somalia, Sam pointed out in class (these questions I posed during a presentation on identity in multilingual settings). The common language among people in Rwanda and among people in Somalia failed to prevent disaster and war.
These questions are really important, I think.
I think Croatian/Serbian is another interesting example too. It's the same language, but many of it's speakers claim they can't understand when the other group speaks, and differences that did exist were exaggerated or invented. Also they are now written in different alphabets.
ReplyDeleteI think kids don't play outside because their online lives and social networks are so much more interesting and important to them. That, and I think parents tend to worry and hover more over kids, preferring to have them in the house with them rather than outside where they'd be unattended.